PDA

View Full Version : Clarification, Identifying Character


Krescen
10-15-2007, 08:36 PM
A significant issues I've found regarding identifying characters is in the instance where a character's gender and a player's gender does not match. While the best policy for this is not something set in stone (so others do not have to follow anything I write), it is the most respectable way to approach the issue.

To stand in comparison, we use the example of an author writing a story. The Author is Female, a Character in the story is Male. To compare, we use an example for online gaming where the Player is Male and his Character is Female. To give names to our examples, we use "Sarah" as the Author, and "Damien" as her character, as well as "Jeff" as the Player, and "Mira" as his character.

Note the use of "her/his" terms in the following:

As Sarah writes [her] book, [she] has [her] character climb a mountain while [he] is being chased by an unknown foe. [He] is trying to transport a precious pendant across hostile territory to safety on the other side of the mountain. At one point [she] has [him] take a rest as [she] sets the stage to ambush [him] by enemies. The moment [he] is attacked, [she] traps the reader's attention by switching to another character.

Sarah owns her character, but is not her character. Any action she does is mentioned with her as reference, but any action her character does is mentioned with him as reference instead. Damien is only a representation of Sarah within her story, as if he was just a messager or servent.

The same works for an online game:

Jeff logs on to [his] character and begins by sending [her] to town to purchase more supplies. [He] had been inattentive to [her] supplies when [he] last played, so now [she] has nearly ran out. [She] goes to the NPC and purchases more supplies. [He] then asks any of his friends if they are available to party, as [she] goes off to find monsters to slay.

The key to the definition is who is inheritly doing the action. Mira is not logging herself on, and Jeff is not going anywhere (he's just sitting at his computer). In the example above, one issue is regarding who is partying with the others. Is Mira the one who is joining the party or is that more of an external action and should be given to Jeff?

As such, we finally reach the purpose of this topic, after having established the above. If you find me calling a male player using the word 'she', it easily can be in the context of the above, I'm making reference to your character and not yourself. I accept the same in return, feel free to refer to my female characters as 'she/her'. I will take offense though if you use 'her/she' to any action which clearly could be attributed to myself and not my character, and if I'm using a male character I had best not have any such reference used in my regard at all. After all, such a game is similar to writing one's own story, the proper words for the story are preferred.

silas101
10-15-2007, 08:39 PM
............well said

hotheadedjonny
10-15-2007, 10:38 PM
Interesting. I don't take offense either way as it can get confusing.

SoraMio
10-15-2007, 10:47 PM
I never get why anyone gets angry when someone refers to them in-game by their character's gender. A boy playing a girl character should expect other players to refer to that character as a female and vice versa. But I've encountered players getting crazy about this type of stuff in-game.

Krescen
10-15-2007, 10:52 PM
I have a habit, for the same reason, of referring to my female characters in the third person on off times (using 'she/her' instead of 'me/my'), and on rare occasions do the same with my own male characters. While it is difficult to apply in practice, it is still the most proper reference.

idane24
10-17-2007, 02:44 AM
me being a YJ often get called "ate" which means sister.. (said with respect)..

i dont mind at all since it is mainly because of the gender lock.. some of the girls here who play YS. often get called "kuya" (brother, respect)>.<

Solstice
10-17-2007, 03:03 AM
This regards to me I guess XD
I was a tamer duing closed beta.
You wouldn't believe how many times I was called a girl.
But I don't care since the odds of seeing that same person again is slim to none.

Krescen
10-17-2007, 03:46 AM
<.< Soul could take it into account, but I wanted it out of the way before OB for myself as well.
>.> And who knows, you might see them again.

Idane, such still goes with what I said above, and applies aptly as such.

Sno
10-17-2007, 06:49 AM
Ah, okay. I really don't mind though xD - keeps Krescen's gender in mind -

Krescen
10-17-2007, 06:53 AM
>.x Sure, make it sound easy to forget. See if I care. >.x

--Goes to hide in a corner-- (or IRC, which ever comes first)

Itto
10-17-2007, 10:15 PM
I've never fully understood the attraction to playing a cross gender role, or cross species for that matter. Practically every game I play I want to play as just basic human male. I just find it really funny that we all seem to assume in mmorpgs that if someone plays as a female elf we assume they are female......and an elf too ;)

MatariChan
10-18-2007, 02:44 PM
Well, here's the thing about playing the cross gender roles. Everyone knows what it's like to be his/her gender, however some of us get thought as to what it would be like to be the opposite gender. I know from experience that female avatars, and male avatars get treated VERY differently unless someone knows the players secret. It's due to a persons curiosity and the anomosity (Sp?) of the internet that one can find out how the sexes treat each other. (not genders, sexes)

On a side note, I found myself confused the first time I read through that Krescen, though now I think I get it.

Lufie
10-18-2007, 03:11 PM
I always pick a female character instead of a male one... I rather have a cute girl instead of a guy running around im my screen :?

Tho I always refear my character as "she" or "it" like:
Lufie leveld today. *woho*
instead of I leveld today :P

Don't kill me for crossplaying :x